Best Weight and Bumper Plates Review December 2018 | Standard vs. Olympic, Rubber vs. Steel

Best Weight and Bumper Plate Reviews 2018

updated December 1, 2018

A quality home gym deserves the best weight and bumper plates. If you thought that a weight was just a weight, then it’s time to get educated. Bumper plates will protect your gym floor if you drop them. Bumpers are also the way to go if you’re heading for competition. In this article, we have located and reviewed the 10 best weight and bumper plates in the 2018 market.

A Quick Glimpse at the Best Weight and Bumper Plates

Our favorite plate is the X Training Equipment Rubber Bumper plates, which gives you a very durable resistance without the odor and oiliness that comes with most bumper plates. It also comes in at a great price point. The CAP Barbell Premium bumper weight also impressed us, with their quality virgin rubber construction and snug, secure fit on the bar.

Our third favorite plate is the X Training Premium plate, which is color coded and extremely rugged and solid fitting on the bar.

Top Ten Weights and Bumpers

We’ve rated the top 10 plates on a simple scale for your convenience. We’ve marked them out of 5 for price and durability and then given an overall rating. Below these ratings you’ll find in-depth reviews of all ten of our top weights and bumpers.​

The 10 Best Weight and Bumper Plates In-Depth

Olympic Bar

XMark Lumberjack Rubber Bumper Plates are made from durable virgin rubber and rubber additives to provide a rugged covering that will take a lot of punishment while being kind to your floor. The Olympic sized center hole has a high quality steel insert which provides for a snug fit on the bar. XMark bumper weights are designed with five recessed grips to make it easy to handle them. They also feature a stainless steel precision hub to ensure an easy, secure fit on the bar.

XMark Lumberjack plates come it an excellent price point and will do an excellent job, especially if you are into CrossFit. In fact, you can get them on a bundle deal complete with a precision lumberjack 7 foot Olympic bar. However, you will have to put up with a strong odor for the first couple of weeks.

PROS

  • ​Strong virgin rubber outer
  • Excellent price
  • Precision steel inserts for snug bar fit

CONS

  • Strong odor
Premium Black Bumper Plate

X Training Equipment Rubber Bumper plates are made from 100% virgin rubber. This eliminates the oily feel and strong smell that is associated with most bumpers. This top quality rubber also adds to the denseness of these plates, making them extremely durable. They slide on and off your Olympic barbell very smoothly and are one of the best value deals on bumper plates that you are likely to find.

X Training Plates have a 2 inch forged stainless steel insert to provide a snug fit to the bar. They are rated to a low bounce for user safety. These plates are designed for low bounce and high durability.

PROS

  • 100% virgin rubber
  • Low bounce rating

CONS

  • Not color coded
Premium Color Bumper Plate

X Training Premium bumper plates are color coded so you can choose your weight at a glance. They are designed for low bounce and high density. They follow the specifications of standard Olympic weights, and have been tested thoroughly by certified Olympic lifters and CrossFit coaches. They feature quality steel inserts on the inner bar hole that fit snugly on any Olympic bar.

X Training Premium weights are more rugged than the soft bumper plates that are readily available online. They are made to survive and thrive through the hardest of workouts and will handle being dropped from height without damaging themselves or the floor. The X Training bumper weights are set at a very competitive price point.

PROS

  • Color coded
  • Low bounce
  • Very durable
  • Great price

CONS

  • These weights gives off an odor for the first week or two
Premium Bumper Plates

CAP Barbell Premium bumper plates are made from virgin and recycled rubber over a cast iron core. This makes them extremely resilient while also have a low bounce factor that will benefit your gym floor. Steel inserts in the plate holes provide a very secure fit on the bar. These plates will not roll along the bar sleeve even in the absence of collars.

Unlike the X Training bumper plates, CAP weights are odorless, so you don’t have to put up with an industrial smell whenever you enter your home gym. All of the CAP plates are the same diameter as a 45 pound steel plate. The thickness of the different weights vary. CAP bumper plates are not color coded, coming in a standard black.

PROS

  • Rubber outer / cast iron core
  • Fit securely on an Olympic bar
  • odorless

CONS

  • Not color coded
Premium Quality Rubber Coated Tri-grip Olympic Plate Weights

The X Mark Premium Tri-gap plates have a triple grip design to allow easy handling. The casing of these weights is made from heavy duty, crack and peel resistant rubber. This protects your floors and adds to the durability and life of the plate. The ergonomically designed recessed center minimizes the risk of pinching your finger when you are loading the plate into an Olympic bar.

X Mark Premium have developed a reputation as among the most accurate producers of weights. That means that you can be assured the actual weight that you’re lifting is what it says on the side of the weight. X Mark means quality, but you will have to put up with a strong chemical odor.

PROS

  • Tri Grip handles
  • Crack and peel resistant rubber casings
  • Recessed center
  • Very accurate weight measure

CONS

  • Very strong chemical odor
160 Lbs Bumper Plates Set

One Fit Wonder Bumper Plates bill themselves as the most durable bumper plates you can get anywhere. That might be overkill, but they are extremely durable. These weights are guaranteed not to crack, bend or break for either 1 year (10 pound ) or 3 years (25 and 45 pound). The plates feature precision crafted steel inserts that will provide for a very snug bar fit.

One Fit Wonder Bumper Plates are extremely accurate. They guarantee that the actual weight will be within 10 grams of the weight on the plate - most weights are only within a 3% margin. These bumper weights are set at a very good price. They are also thinner than most weights, so you can get more poundage on the bar.

PROS

  • Extremely hard wearing
  • Thin width design
  • Very accurate weighting

CONS

  • Strong odor
Black Rubber Bumper Plates

The Rep Fitness range of bumper plates come in black rubber and have large white numbering on them. The weights are fitted with a metal sleeve for enhanced fit and easy sliding onto the bar. Rep Fitness use only the most high quality, resilient rubber, rather than the crumb rubber which is used by many competitors. These plates are extremely low odor so they won’t stink up your gym.

The molds used by Rep Fitness are chrome plated. This ensures a consistent quality finish and helps to keep the plates within a very close margin of weight. REP Fitness weights are 17.7 inches in diameter, with small variation in the thickness according to the weight of the plate. The 45 pound plate is thinner than the competition so that you can fit more weight on the bar. These weights don’t smell and comes in at an impressive price point.

PROS

  • High quality metal sleeve
  • Best quality rubber used for casing
  • Very low odor

CONS

  • Not color coded
Black Olympic Plates

The Ader Sports Olympic plates are finished in a stylish black satin metal and feature contrasting white numbers and lettering. Their centers are precision drilled to two inches and fitted with a metal sleeve to enhance the fit on the bar. The flat side of the hole has been machine milled. The ridges on the outside of the plate makes it easy to grip and carry.

The Ader plates are accurate to within 1% of the weight stated on the plate. These are among the few weights that go as low as 1.25 pounds. This allows for micro-loading when you are trying to get your poundage up. This is a huge advantage.

PROS

  • Stylish black satin finish
  • Plates go down to 1.25 pounds for micro-loading
  • Outside ridges make it easy to carry

CONS

  • Slight weight variance
Hi Temp Bumper Plates

The Rogue range of Hi Temp bumper plates are among the few that are actually made in the USA. That means that Rogue have total control over the quality. They use only the highest grade recycled vulcanized crumb rubber. A two inch stainless steel insert makes sure that the weight slides on easily and sits securely on the bar.

A small but important detail is that the collars on these bumper weights are inset from the plane of the plate. This makes for enhanced safety when you have a number of weights loaded onto the bar. Rogue bumper plates have an impressive tolerance of +/- 0.5 pounds. They are among the most popular bumper weights on the planet.

PROS

  • Made in USA
  • Highest quality vulcanized rubber construction
  • Collars inset for safety

CONS

  • Strong Odor
York Legacy Iron Plates

York Legacy Iron plates are a throwback to the classic York barbell weight of the ‘60’s. It is a replica of the original York Olympic standard weight. These weights are precision milled to be within 2% of the indicated weight. They feature an indent on the lip to make it easy to carry the weight. The fit on an Olympic bar is snug and true due to the precision drilled center hole.

The York Legacy Olympic Bar features the distinctive white YORK Olympic Standard Barbell lettering molded on it’s face. Buy them for the nostalgic value alone!

PROS

  • The original York Barbell design
  • Easy to carry
  • Precision milled

CONS

  • Expensive

Should you buy metal weights or bumper plates for your home gym? Get the facts from this informative video and decide for yourself . . .

Conclusion

The best weight and bumper plate for the home gym market that we found was the X Training Equipment Bumper Plate, with it’s great combination of strength, resilience, lack of odor and great price point. We also loved the CAP Barbell Premium bumper weight which is also a very strong, durable plate with no odor and has a very snug fit on the bar.

Our bronze medal winning plate is the X Training Premium plate, which is color coded and has low bounce and high density.

Top 3 Weight and Bumper Plates

X Mark Lumberjack Bumper Plate Set


Our #1. Recommendation

X Mark Lumberjack Bumper Plate Set

jim roose

My name is Jim Roose. I'm a former competitive power lifter and gym owner. I've bought millions of dollars of fitness equipment over the last 20 years. This site is my way of giving back to the fitness community that's done so much for me. Every article on here is carefully researched and written by me. Leave a comment if you have any questions.

Best Weight and Bumper Plate Reviews 2018
4.5 (90%) 8 votes